Lock ’Em Up?


A father in an incomprehensible blur makes a terrible mistake. He drops his shoeless 2-year-old son off alongside Houston Mesa Road — and drives away. Astonishing. Frightening. Terrible.

Fortunately, a passing Good Samaritan sees the child, stops, gathering him up and takes him to Payson Regional Medical Center. A short while later, officers discover the befuddled and irresponsible father with several friends searching desperately for the child.

The man initially admits abandoning the child, then later says that in a daze from over-the-counter drugs he hallucinated that he was dropping the child off where the mother — his estranged girlfriend — could pick him up.

The Gila County Attorney’s Office initially threatened to charge him with child abuse, neglect and abandonment charges that could yield a 17-year prison term. With that enormous threat, the man accepted a plea bargain that requires a minimum sentence of 3.5 years.

Now here’s the twist. He has other children. The mother of the child he abandoned alongside the road, said he’s a good father. The children miss him. She needs his help and support. She pleaded with the court to place him on intensive probation. So did the child’s grandmother.

But the judge had accepted the plea deal — which required jail time. So off to jail he goes.

Did he make a terrible, even intolerable mistake?

No doubt about it.

Will locking him up in prison for 3.5 years serve the interests of justice — and the child he neglected?

Well — we’ve got lots of doubts about that.


Pat Randall 3 years, 1 month ago

This is why plea agreements should be thrown out the window. If you are accused of something that is what you should be tried on. Not take a plea agreement that isn't close to what happened. It just makes it easier, and quicker for the attorneys and judges. Either you do something or you don't. Be judged on that. The man first made a mistake for taking all the pills, how come he wasn't charged for using drugs? Even tho they were over the counter there are warnings on them. Who will support his family while he is sitting in jail? Will they be better off without him for 3 and 1/2 years?


H. Wm. Rhea III 3 years, 1 month ago

Agreed. They should be tried for their crimes and if found guilty be appropriately punished.


Requires free registration

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.