Rumsey Plan

The $43 million overhaul of Rumsey Park to include ice rinks, a covered pool, a community center and new athletic fields would generate $1.4 million annually in membership fees and another $3.8 million in partnership, leases, marketing and other revenue, according to a consultant’s report.

As Mayor Craig Swartwood’s term comes to a close, a project he hoped would revitalize Rumsey Park and the economy died a quiet death Thursday night. The council dissolved an agreement with Valley-based consulting group Community Center Partners LLC and Varxity Development.

The town originally approved a tri-party contract in September 2017 for the development of the Rumsey Park master plan. The town and Varxity each put in $125,000 for CCP to draft the plan. That resulted in an ambitious strategy to rework the layout of the park, relocating ball fields, adding walking paths, new dog and skate parks, pool, community center and two ice skating rinks.

Varxity had hoped to build a college preparatory school in Payson and use the park facilities.

CCP said financing for the $43 million complex would come from private sources, secured by revenue generated by the facilities.

To secure that financing and “validate” the plan, CCP required another $500,000. The town asked the Friends of Payson Parks and Recreation to collect donations. The group reportedly collected less than $50,000, although pledges totaled $125,000.

For all that the plan promised to deliver, many residents were leery.

In August, voters approved two propositions, 401 and 402, “which may have a direct effect on the future of Rumsey Park, thus impacting the validation process,” according to a town resolution. Then in September, donors requested their money back for phase 1 of validation.

With no money to see the project continue, the town, CCP and Varxity met and mutually agreed to terminate the agreement. Councilor Barbara Underwood “regretfully” motioned to approve the resolution Thursday night. It passed unanimously.

Contact the reporter at

Covers breaking news, cops, courts, fire and the Town of Payson.

(1) comment


It's a shame that Swartwood and the council didn't first ask the town residents if they even wanted the ice hock prep school and loss of local control of our park, prior to making these decisions. It may have saved many thousands of dollars on yet, another 'study'! Perhaps now we can move forward with a new mayor and council, to come up with a COMMON SENSE plan to renovate the park, build a year round pool, and a community center, that WE THE PEOPLE maintain control of. Let's move forward!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Avoid obscene, hateful, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful.
Be Nice. No name-calling, racism, sexism or any sort of -ism degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article. Real names only!